The MiniDrive review
No, this isn’t the Nifty MiniDrive. Instead, its simply called MiniDrive (theminidrive.com). Yes. These two can be confusing as both addresses the exact same issue and both has very similar names. While I’m not going into discussing which came out with the idea first, I would however have to make comparisons between the two.
Full Discloser: The MiniDrive Air unit that I received was sent to me as a review unit.
Let’s start with the price and availability.
There are essentially two versions of the MiniDrive. One without the faceplate and another with the faceplate that fits all versions of the MacBook, similar to the Nifty MiniDrive. The price of the MiniDrive without the faceplate US$20 on Amazon, or US$22 on eBay. And the ones with the faceplates are going for about US$30 on Amazon. But they do have a goal of making a US$6 MiniDrive, essentially using the proceeds they receive from the sales of the US$20-30 MiniDrives to fund the development of this cheaper MiniDrive. But it’s also important to note that the MiniDrive is available today! You can order it now and receive it as soon as it’s shipped out to you.
I’m sure many of us will also compare this with the Nifty MiniDrive which was priced at US$25 for the kickstarter backers. While there are no news on the final retail price, we can all be certain that it would be priced above the Kickstarter pledge levels, US$30 maybe? Availability unfortunately is not for the Nifty MiniDrive. Unless your were one of the Kickstarter project backer, you’re out of luck from being able to purchase a Nifty MiniDrive at this point in time since it’s not available for retail yet.
So to summarise, pricing wise at this point (although not a fair comparison) both are roughly the same, with the MiniDrive being both cheaper and more expensive depending on the model. However, the MiniDrive has the advantage of being available right now.
Now, for the looks and functionality of the MiniDrive.
The gallery above pretty much shows you how the MiniDrive looks like when you receive it.
Generally, the built quality of the SD Card adapter itself seems better when compared to the Nifty MiniDrive. The Nifty ones at it’s current version has the problems of the top cover (the one with the Nifty word printed) as some has complained that it does not attach well to the body. A number of Nifty MiniDrives also suffered from the read-only problem due to its design. And on this note, the MiniDrive does not suffer from this problem, which is a great plus point compare to the Nifty MiniDrive’s design.
However, the faceplate of the MiniDrive which
is made of plastic and spray painted with metallic silver paint even though made of a special a plastic with suspended aluminium flakes, cannot compare aesthetically with the Nifty MiniDrive’s faceplate which is made of aluminium. And the fit of the MiniDrive’s faceplate while ok, isn’t as well fitted as the Nifty MiniDrive too. But the Nifty MiniDrive also suffers from issues of the faceplate being detached from the body when strained, apparently due to manufacturing (glue) issues. This problem and the read-only problem has forced the Nifty team to revamp the design AFTER they manufactured the batch for the kickstarter backers. And this is where the MiniDrive fares better. Looking at the way the MiniDrive is design, it does not seem like it would face the issues that some of us Nifty MiniDrive owners had faced.
So aesthetically, the Nifty MiniDrive scores full points. But functionally, the MiniDrive is better overall since there’s less chances of failure.
The only last complain that I have with the MiniDrive is on its removal process. As you’ve seen on the photos above, they bundled together a red wire that’s to be used to pull out the MiniDrive. Loss the wire (which is extreme easy to) and you’d need to search high and low for something that’s as thin to hook the MiniDrive out when you need to. I would have liked the hole on the faceplate to be slightly larger to accommodate perhaps a paperclip that is easily found anywhere, or provide a proper removal tool that you can hook to your keychain, like the one provided along with the Nifty MiniDrive.
Update: The guys at MiniDrive gave me a tip if you lose the red wire, a staple (from the stapler of course) will work too.
So in summary…
Both the MiniDrive and the Nifty MiniDrive has their pros and cons.
The MiniDrive Pros:
- It’s available now!
- It works well. No read-only issues, no faceplate detachment problems
The MiniDrive Cons:
- The price seems expensive (although there is the promise of the US$6 version)
- Aesthetically less pleasing compared to the Nifty MiniDrive
And again, if you think the MiniDrive is for you, here are the links to purchase them on both Amazon and eBay.